It’s a little-known secret that Arab women don’t just marry Arab men, they marry within the same village as their family if they can, first. If they don’t, their husband will be considered as “Ghareeb” (strangers), even if the town they hail from is only 10 minutes away. (Disclaimer: Lots of women are stepping away from this tribal way of marriage. I happen to be one of those women.)
So, just imagine the reaction I received from my family when I said I am marrying an Indian.
I would love to say that they were open-minded about it, as mentioned before, some Arab families may not mind (as long as the guy is Muslim…or a doctor), but this wasn’t the case for me.
I don’t want to say all of my family were haters. Thankfully, my siblings were very supportive of the idea and loved him regardless, which gave me the courage to dial the number and call my aunt overseas.
My aunt’s approval was so important to me because she was the woman who raised me. She was also well respected within our family — so if she approved, everyone would eventually follow suit.
I remember that moment that I dialed her number. I heard the beat of my heart louder than I heard the phone ringing as I waited for her to pick up. I remember after the typical “hellos” and “how are you’s?” how I felt and sounded as I told her about Assif. With a shakey voice I said, “A suitable, very nice MUSLIM man asked for my hand.”
Yes, Mentioning that he was Muslim was really important in hopes that it would be enough reason for her to be happy about it since I was living alone at that time.
I don’t know what I was thinking, because really…that didn’t change anything. Her first question was, “Which Hamola?” which meant “which family/tribe is he from?” She wanted to know if he was from our village.
My aunt’s approval was so important to me because she was the woman who raised me. She was also well respected within our family — so if she approved, everyone would eventually follow suit.
“Not from our hometown,” I said.
“Which town?” She asked.
“Well…not from a town located in Palestine.”
“Is he Jordanian or Egyptian?” she asked.
“No, he is Indian. Muslim, though for me, though.”
*Click*
Did we just get disconnected? I called her back and I explained to her what a great man he is and that he comes from a great family, but all I heard was her crying on the other end, interrupted by one word every few seconds.
What word was it? “Ajnabi,” which was an even stronger word to expand on “Ghareeb.” It was more than stranger — it was foreign.
When my mother saw that feelings were starting to develop between Assif and me in college, she went out of her way to introduce to me to other guys. She tried to set me up with an Egyptian man once, hoping I’d like him more than my Indian love.
Here’s the strange thing. I am Palestinian. So, when my family couldn’t think of an eligible Palestinian available, they reluctantly ventured outside of our own nationality to Egypt — because Egypt was still Arab, at least. Because — apparently any Arab understands us better than a non-Arab, right?
The irony I found in this very tribal and exclusive mindset of Arab Muslims who prefer Arabs over non Arab Muslims is that they are often the same people advocating for issues such as Black Lives Matter, or Free Kashmir — while quoting Ghandi regarding justice and equality. The hypocrisy of it all is too much for me to take at times.
Fortunately, my aunt eventually came around and understood that the man I wanted was perfect for me. And she was right into finally coming around. More than a decade later, my husband and I are blessed with a beautiful life together with a child and a good home.
I wish I could say the same for other family members, though. Many of them cut relations with me. It took years for me to work at mending those severed ties — but that only came after time and opportunities to have actual conversations with him to know what a good man he was and is, regardless of his background.
I understand the importance of sharing the same religion, but beyond that, there shouldn’t be any restrictions regarding race or nationality — specifically when it comes to getting married.
What I’ve learned in life is that we have this hidden racism covered by chants of justice and equality to mask the shame of this “better than other people” attitude and belief.
How many of our Arab brothers and sisters marching at rallies for Black Lives Matter would be willing to allow their daughters to marry a Black Muslim? How many of you Arab Muslim mothers and fathers who are preaching pluralism among your friends and colleagues are open to your daughter bringing home a man from Pakistan to marry?
How many of our Arab brothers and sisters marching at rallies for Black Lives Matter would be willing to allow their daughters to marry a Black Muslim? How many of you Arab Muslim mothers and fathers who are preaching pluralism among your friends and colleagues are open to your daughter bringing home a man from Pakistan to marry?
Out of curiosity, are our Arab Muslim sons getting the same reactions and negative feedback from their parents if they bring home a non-Arab woman to marry? I already know the answer to that question: NO!
Racism is prohibited in Islam — but unfortunately, sometimes we confuse what’s culturally forbidden with what’s religiously prohibited or encouraged. It is important that in the Muslim community (mosques, marriages, friendship, etc.) that we disconnect from what’s culturally important to us and concentrate on what’s religiously important.
It is important for families to find suitable Muslim men or women for their kids, regardless of the background or countries.
It is important that in the Muslim community (mosques, marriages, friendship, etc.) that we disconnect from what’s culturally important to us and concentrate on what’s religiously important.
I don’t want anyone to dismiss someone’s color, background, culture, or language — as they are important part of shaping that person’s life. But that shouldn’t be the reason or the focus to not approve a marriage.
—
Written by Ranna Abdeljawad
My thoughts exactly, amazing piece!
“Out of curiosity, are our Arab Muslim sons getting the same reactions and negative feedback from their parents if they bring home a non-Arab woman to marry? I already know the answer to that question: NO!”
Um, actually the answer is yes. As an Arab who married an Indian, I’ve faced it, still face it, and have seen other male Arab freinds face it. I do agree that is definitely seen as “worse” when it’s the other way around, I cannot deny that, but please don’t make blanket statements like that.
Otherwise, I’m happy to hear that things for your husband and yourself worked out and that you’re both happy.
Yes. The answer is YES. I am an American woman married to an Arab man..and YES! Men are getting the same reactions if they don’t bring home an Arab woman.
Very true! I am Puerto Rican and my husband Egyptian. At first his family and even mines were not supportive and didn’t want us to get married but we remained patient for 5 years. Our families have changed their perspective on marrying “outside” of our nationalities and have come to love us and support us.
If you don’t mind me asking.. What changed their minds during those 5 years?
What was your relationship like during those years of waiting
I think you misread this and are perhaps talking past each other. The OP didn’t say that men were entirely liberated from the pressure to marry inside the race. She just said they’re not getting the same reactions. You’re acknowledging the reactions aren’t the same (by degree) and disagreeing with the statement. You’re both right. It’s worse the other way around, and the reactions and negative feedback are not “the same.”
The answer is… YES. Especially if they are from a well-to-do family.
I’m an American who married a Palestinian man and his family did everything they could to find him a Palestinian woman before we got married.
I agree. I just dated an Egyptian man who was wonderful in every way possible except that he will not marry a woman that was not born and raised in Egypt. He will not even marry an Egyptian woman raised in Canada. The interesting thing about this is that he is spiritual but not religious. He didn’t consider himself Arab. Another Egyptian man I knew who was religious and did consider himself Arab and did marry outside of his culture.
Your article was great ! You completely hit every point/ aspect of multicultural marriages in the Arab community perfectly, it a sad truth but it is definitely a truth in our society! As a Mutt myself I’d like to say thank you for shedding a little light on this subject as it always falls back under the category of ” lost children “… The label ” bunt el ajnabi “( daughter of the American)has followed me to this day , regardless of the fact that I was raised overseas. My parents have been happily married for 45 years now & if I’m to be honest they are the only happy couple I saw growing up , I might even go as far as to say have seen in our community ever ! So needless to say the idea of only marring from within our own tribe is not about the happiness of our children nor the wellbeing of the next generation…
The truth is that is everwhere
Desis ( Pakistani and Indian Muslims) do not want their children( sons or daughters) to marry Arabs because the culture and language are vastly different . It is still not accepted and the common perception is that they do not fit in with the family . They do not want their sons or daughters to marry outside the desi community.
The irony is that in setting you up with an Egyptian, the Egyptians themselves don’t like to think of themselves as “Arab” which is beneath them. No they say they are from the royal Egyptian lineage to prop themselves up more.
My husband is Egyptian and I am Puerto Rican and He never says I am not Arab. I can’t speak for others but I am thankful my husband doesn’t consider himself royal. He is a humble man and has the most kind heart.
I was married to an Egyptian long ago. When I called him Arab, we was very indignant, said Egyptians are not Arabs, they are Egyptians. Most Egyptians i met feel the same way, they do not consider themselves as Arab.
Let me tell you something, if you insisted on rebelling against your parents’ wishes and married a non-arab, that is your choice but dont bring your liberal marxist propaganda and try to push other Arabs to marry non-arabs. Elhamdulila I made sure all my 3 young sisters married arabs, and elhamdulila there husbands are all good men. I did not even let them think of bringing a muslim Somalian, Indian, Bosnian…etc, I told them Islam is a religion between you and Allah, not because someone is muslim means you will get along with them in marriage. Culture plays a huge role, most mixed marriages end up in divorce, especially with non-muslim mixed marriages (ex. black and white)…besides, why destroy your culture and genes that was built by over thousands of years of Arab ancestry. Why destroy your heritage and mix just to prove your “open-minded”….IF we all mixed there will be no diversity because everyone would be of mixed heritage and no one has a culture to bring forth and share their wonderful cuisines/music/art….imagine no more world cultural day because we are all mixed. I advise all indian muslims, arab muslims, somali muslims, whatever Muslim to marry your own culture so that you can bring forth a new generation of diversity for our kids to learn from one another. One choosing for his sisters , daughters to marry from their own race is not racism,,,,,its called picking a like-minded spouse. The Israel would love if all Palestinian men and palestinian women married non-arabs, then it would be easier for them to forget their ancestral homeland and not care about the situation in Palestine. They will say “Yea…my grandmother was Palestinian, but oh well, i mixed so it doesn’t really matter…”. It is Israel’s dream to ensure that a Palestinian generation is lost by mixing with non-Arabs.
Salam Alikom
Didnt the prophet (peace be upon him) once said that “NO arabs are superior than non arabs, and NO Non arabs are superior than arabs.”?
Does Hajj failed to teach us a lesson? That everyone is equal infront of Allah? No matter from which nationality we are, what our proffesion are, and any other wordly aspects. No it doesnt matter. What matter are the eman and taqwa. The hajj teach us that islam Can and should be able to delete racism in all forms.
And also, as a muslim, dont we all agree that the rizk, the spouse and death are already written by Allah the Almighty? All we need to do is to ask Allah for the best one for us ACORDING to Him. So how about if Allah said that the best one for us is not from among our village or nation? (Yes we do have istikharah to ask Allah to lead the life we have and not just simply following the nafs). For the sake of the cultural thing, are we going to against whats good for us acording to Him?
Proud arab, your mind was just overwhelming for me. Sadly, i expect more from muslims about Non Racist issues as we have the thaught from our one God through the beloved prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him)
Just fyi, i am in a mix marriage life with egyptian and never been this happy alhamdulillah.
This said more than article. What racist trash!
I feel exactly the same. I am a white Muslim and I won’t marry a non European. Allah made us into certain colors and tribes for a reason.
When did you decide this. I think you’re trolling,
Lauren Ann Rossell 9 months ago
Im a white divorced Muslim and have always wanted to marry a Saudi. ..I don’t know why? Lol
O you mankind, surely We created you of a male and a female, and We have made you races and tribes that you may get mutually acquainted. Surely the most honorable among you in the Providence of Allah are the most pious; surely Allah is Ever-Knowing, Ever-Cognizant. s49/v13 :’)
Indeed. Islam killed racism long time ago and whoever is a Muslim and a racist, you are doing it wrong! I really do feel sorry for proud Arab as he/she clearly is stuck in the Quraysh era!! I will be open to marry any one as long as he is a Muslim and as long as my heart beats for him.
and what will u do if after marriage he decides to leave islam? will u still love him?
Unfortunately we can’t control our hearts so I can’t say I will not still love him! But in the end of the day I am a Muslim woman and my loyalty and love is for my Creator. So to answer your question yes I will have to leave him and no I don’t know about still loving! I hope I never find myself in such situation 🙂
Allah made us into different nations and tribes so that we could come to know each other. It is in the Quran.
Btw…I am a white American proud Muslimah married to a Palestinian. He is the love of my life and I his. I have never been happier. Allah truly blessed me when He bestowed Islam upon me and He brought my husband into my life. My husband is the best man I have ever known.
Wow. What a racist pig and a dreadful Muslim you are. The rest of us are lucky we are not your sisters. How the hell do you know if they are “good men”? Do YOU live with them? Do YOU have to sleep with them? Do YOU have to spend your whole life with them? You’re HORRIBLE. I hope you are infertile.
Who is the racist, you went on a rant of abuse when the Arab man ( proud-Arab) said something, but when the White woman (Laurnen Ann Rossell) said exactly the same thing.. Silence
Who is the racist?
Ask your self and may Allah guide you.
Couldn’t pull that one me. A bit disappointed? I said something to both of them before you did. They’re both racist trash. But, it looks like Laurnen Ann Rossell is a troll. Interestingly, you chose to speak in defense of the racist Arab (proud-Arab), and not in defense of the white racist (not that I would advocate you do that). That makes your position both less moral and less consistent. I gave both of them scorn.
Questioning inconsistency does not equate to defences.
My position on this subject is undecided as I have seem marriages fail due to culture. However logically and Islamiclly they are fine.
Btw the article itself is a fabrication as I noticed the few Arabic words in there did not match the regional dialect of Palestinian or Egyptain Arabs.
Isn’t the whole premise of your argument that inconsistency does equate to defense?
> but when the White woman (Laurnen Ann Rossell) said exactly the same thing.. Silence Who is the racist? Ask your self and may Allah guide you.
You accused AussieKim of being racist because she isolated proud-Arab when she claimed racism rather than being consistent and naming Laurnen Ann Rossell too.
Yes I would suggest that what is good for the goose is good for the gander.
Go watch sheikh omar Suleiman
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=zsLdu5Z4Dws
You sand niggers are the reason why ppl don’t feel bad when Israel bombs you! People who accomplish nothing in life and are nothing in life are proud of their nationality! Your nationality is not sn accomplishment! I blame your ignorance on that arab inbreeding! You have the nerve to talk as if anyone wants you! You’re the ones obsessing over fair dkinned Europeans! You self hating pieces of trash! Islam can to eradicate your stupidity and you still insist on clinging to your ignorance
“Sand niggers” thats new and creative.
I suppose you presume in your ignorance that I am Saudi because of the cloths, these clothes are worn in the whole of the gulf, Iraq, Syria, Jordan and Palestine. But what would something like you know.
No worries, the fact that you are a cowardly individual who hides their identity with a female English name is enough to invalidate your opinion and make you a none person.
I feel sorry for things like you. Living to hate must be very tiring, it turns you into a thing not a person.
truth hurts dont it? actually I know alot! something like you? the only something here is you! your desperate attempt to sound relevent is surreal! Speak to and for yourself,the only coward here is yourself! YOURE BEHIND A COMPUTER YOURSELF! I would love to see what scale you measure courage with? you have a tainted despicable view of courage!
How do you know I live to hate? because I responded to your drivel! the mental gymnastics demonstrated in your fallacy is beyond hilarious!
also, why do u ASSume Im male? lool,maybe in ur shithole of a nation women dont stand up to bitchmade males…but we o here and around the world! so kick rocks ya abd al ramla
I go further you are a male homosexual who is in the closet who has had a bad expieriance with an Arab. That is why you are so bitter. I feel sorry for you the hatered is eating you up. Come out and find yourself a boyfriend and maybe you will feel a bit better.
As for the nation I come from , you don’t know where I come from, I may even be living next to you, but you presume because youy need to. That hate and bitterness that burns your every waking hour makes you want to blame someone, feel free, as long as you are sitting verbally abusing Arabs on the net, you are not going out and attacking boys so fine.
I know you are not a woman and you are not English.
Because of your writing style and bad grammar.
The most likely is that you are an Asian homosexual and in the closet. If you have had a bad experience with an Arab I am sorry. Why not go find a boy friend, get real with yourself and loss all the hate that must be eating your soul up. To go through life hating people you don’t know must be a very terrible feeling I feel genuinely sorry for you.
Aussie,
This is a cultural thing and not religious. Your really ignorant.
Who is the racist, you went on a rant of abuse when the Arab man ( proud-Arab) said something, but when the White woman (Laurnen Ann Rossell) said exactly the same thing.. Silence
Who is the racist?
Ask your self and may Allah guide you.
I’m not wanting to fight, I just want to understand. If my husband (Arab) and I (American) are both Muslims, explain how our marriage isn’t good? We both love Allah, pray, etc. Why does it matter what our culture does? We both get along with each other’s family, and we exchange cultural ideas and practices. I think that is a very good thing. I have enlightened Americans that I know about Arab culture, and he has done the same for Arabs that he knows (about American culture). Everyday we wake up happy. I see nothing wrong with that. It’s not “liberal- Marxist propaganda.” It’s real, and it’s my life.
I agree but not totally brother.
I am.not arab, but genetically im arabic,, my wife is a yemenia and is my grandfather.
I dont blame arabs because there are plenty of arabs , even in the yemen, people think im from emirate and if I say ” Ana mesh arabi bas zawajti arabi, yemenia, ana hindi”… no one in the yemen hesitate to being racist,, my wife’s dad was a cool man, he is a doctor, so he asked me ” where r u from? I said ” India born, malaysian citizen”.. he then asked me why u not marry malay in your country instead marrying my daughter?.. i answered marriage is about heart likes heart, so, I just love her, you have plenty of choices on earth, but the one I trully love would be one”
he was impressed, he said ” wallah, I like the way u talk, I will accept you”
her mom who is a yemeni, being racist by saying why u marry hindi above yemeni man?.. then when I meet her, I said aunty, I love you as my mom,, suddenly she cried and blame everyone brainwashing her amongst her community and both of em agreed to our marriage.
we are now happy, and Its just what has happened, marriage is a matter of god’s decision, it has nothing to do with us.
Be it indian or arab or european or african or asian, you are what you are..
Race brought nothing, but misleading us towards hostility.
And to be frankly, we are all from one father that has no difference between all of us. but if u still wanna look for that, congrats.
Am indian-yemeni by genetics, and malaysian by modernity.
So, I am all in one.
You should do the same
Just be a Hyderabadi (India) Muslim — Hyderabadi Mothers are MORE than happy to accept any color (black, white, yellow, purple, etc.,,) under the rainbow Muslim Men —- AS LONG AS THEY ARE OVERALL ‘GREEN’, as in green dollars, or for that matter whatever color there currency is in; alot of times, even not being Muslim (AstigfurAllah) is alright to — so long as they Groom to be is a ‘Dakhtaarrrrr’; don’t believe me?? Have a honest, confident one-on-one with another Hyderabadi and he will tell you
Appreciate the insight. I’ve seen and heard a lot of these stories from the woman’s perspective. You’re especially strong for knowing how your family would receive this and still letting your heart guide you. A lot of love is snuffed out of fear of the consequences of challenging racist endogamy. Hope your marriage lasts and you’re both forever happy.
Appearance over substance. I am lucky, a’H in that my wife’s family is very open for a Yemen family. Uncles had married white women, cousins had married white men. We still get stares from other Muslims more than anyone else. My wife used to be seen as the traditional girl, the one whose other people’s mothers would say “be more like her.” I am sure they dont say that any more, lol, but her family treat me wonderfully and her and I get along great, so who cares. I am white, she is Yemenia.
I sincerely enjoyed your article, however… Yes, Muslim Arab men still get back lash from relatives for marrying ‘ghoriya’… My husband is Tunisian and his family certainly does not approve of me. I was Muslim prior to even knowing him. 4 kids later, no relationship with them what so ever. I am extremely familiar with Arabs from Yemen all the way to Maghrib and your struggle isn’t unique to Arabs alone, Pakis, Afghanis, Indians, hell even Chinese Muslims go through this. Tribal mentality is alive and well even among non Muslims within the continental US. Ask a hill billy red neck mother in law what she thinks of her ‘yankee’ daughter in law or vice versa.
In the end it all boils down to education and dean. I also view the reasons why Arabs in particular do not want their children to marry outside the blad has to do with:
1. Keeping the wealth within the family.
2. Lowering the divorce risk.
As a mother who happens to be an American, I’ve been asked why I am so opposed to my kids marrying non Muslims.. well, I wouldn’t want my son for example to marry a non Muslim female who isn’t strict, end up divorced, his kids living in a house with a boyfriend, getting molested, him taken to the cleaners paying alimony because she refuses to work, her and the new boyfriend sailing off into the sunset neglecting my future grand children. (I am 33)
Of course my statements might seem ‘close minded’ and it’s strange since I am an American and I think this way, but human beings prefer familiarity. Do I condone racism? No.. Rasoul (saws) married multiple women from different tribes.. Did so for political reasons of course.. but the most talked about wives, Kadija and Aiesha (ra) to them both were familiar.
Alhumdu’Allah, your marriage is going strong insha’Allah it stays that way. Proud of you for shattering stereo types. Keep your head up. Bid’dah is always going to be there and as much as we try to change other people’s minds in the end we just live our lives doing what in our hearts we feel is right. Often, if you let those you care about comprehend that you UNDERSTAND where they are coming from and respect their fears, they’ll come around. <3
I don’t think that is a fair description of non Muslim women. Who in their right minds want a marriage to end in divorce? Especially when there are children involved? By your own statements you sounded to me no different than those ignorant bible thumping “Christians” when they talk about Muslims. Whichever way it comes from to me those kinds of stereotypes are disgusting and do not align with either religion. Ironically both Christianity and Islam have so much in common yet I have found that those that follow both end up doing the exact opposite of the intentions of the values they instill. It’s so disheartening to see that humanity – outside of technology – has done very little growth and is still stuck whether overtly or not in attitudes that are 500 or more years old.
I also think it’s important to understand that a person can also find love outside the religion as well. A Muslim girl can marry a non Muslim just a Muslim boy can marry a non Muslim. I hate the double standards
This seems like my story. At first my parents werent ready for this but now they are okkay with that. Her parents are still not ready. please pray for me and suggest how can I make it possible…:)
As a Muslim American Arab Man.
This issue exists in every race, culture, etc.
It’s just unfortunate the Arab & Muslim bashers feed off of this thing.
I have dealt with Christians and other races that are 1 Million times worse then my Arab & Muslim brothers & sisters.